In the film industry, there's a term called “MacGuffin”. This is where our hero suddenly encounters an obstacle that moves the plot forward. An example we’ve all seen is when our hero attempts to make a phone call, only to find that there is no service available. No matter what our hero tries, the lines are down, so now they have to continue on their quest without the aid of modern technology.
This is the most common way people learn about jammers, but do they actually exist? Do they actually work, or is this more than sci‑fi gadgetry? In this post, I’m going to answer this question without getting into how to build or misuse anything. Let’s go over what audio jammers are, their effectiveness, legitimate reasons why people need them, and their advantages and disadvantages. There is, of course, the legal issue and the ethical side that cannot be ignored. I strongly recommend checking your local, state, and national laws. Please note that this article is for educational purposes only, to help you stay more informed and give you peace of mind.
What Is An Audio Jammer? (Jamming, Masking)
An Audio Jammer is a device that emits (creates) a sound that is intended to interfere with a recording device. The emitted sound incapacitates the recorder, rendering all the audio unintelligible and overwhelming its function. If you played the recording affected by a jammer through an audio spectrum analyzer, it would reveal a wall of sound that swamps any usable information. The jammer will either emit a short-wave or high-frequency audio signal that buries the conversation in the environment, keeping what is being said safe and secure.
In practice, there are multiple ways this can be accomplished; some audio jammers produce sound outside the spectrum of what the human ear is capable of hearing. They run “quietly” and don’t distract those who are a part of the conversation. Other devices produce white noise, or an audible sound level that can be loud enough to mask conversations within it. This is what's called sound masking, and these make noise but render information within that decibel spectrum moot.
Important: That's the theory; both concepts have advantages and disadvantages, and there are situations where each can be ideal.
Do Audio Jammers Work?
The Short answer is sometimes, but not always. Many salespeople in the industry will claim that an audio jammer will replace the need for a proper bug sweep, and under very specific, controlled circumstances, they're telling the truth. However, the world is not black and white, and it may deter more casual individuals; audio jammers can be defeated. If the goal of the person trying to record is to achieve crystal-clear, high-fidelity audio, then an audio jammer will perform flawlessly; however, this is a very specific circumstance. Several factors, including the type of jammer, the microphone of the recorder, distance, and even the natural acoustics of the environment, will influence the results.
For example, suppose you're trying to use an audio jammer that relies on white noise in an open-air environment. In that case, the white noise will disperse in all directions and become ineffective, as it cannot utilize the environment's acoustics to target the recording device. At the same time, an audio jammer that relies on an inaudible high-frequency noise will only be effective if the audio recorder can detect that high-frequency noise. Something as simple as having an audio recorder in a jacket pocket could buffer the high-frequency noise enough to allow for clear recording of the conversation.
Here are some other factors that may affect the results:
-
Microphone Type: Smartphone mics are designed with background noise reduction in mind, while some hidden microphones are designed for long-distance noise pickup
-
Distance: Audio jammers are generally designed for short-range usage; if things such as line of sight are lost, either to the conversation or the recorder, then their effectiveness drops off.
-
Environment: Rooms with good acoustics assist the jammer's effective range, but echo-prone environments, reflective surfaces, and even ceiling height can play key factors in the results. In a small, controlled, and quiet room, for example, the spoken dB level of the occupants will be reduced, allowing the jammer to have more control.
-
Sophistication: Different Jammers broadcast different barriers, such as tones, noise, and frequency-interfering signals, with varying defences in mind, while some audio recorders and even post-production programs and tools can reduce these barriers and extract information. The better the quality of the device, the more opportunities it has to overcome these obstacles.
-
Redundancy: There's an old saying, “Have a backup for your backup.” Having multiple types of jammers in use will increase the level of protection, and at the same time, having multiple recorders in use will provide more opportunities to overcome the jammer as an obstacle. This is the difference between a novice and a professional. Ensuring that you have multiple fail-safes in play will significantly increase the chance of success.
Masking Sound vs. Jamming Sound
|
Masking |
Jamming |
|
|
Goal |
Disrupts the dB level and masks a conversation. |
Disrupt a recording device with a wall of high- or low-frequency sound. |
|
Technology |
Adds audible noise to the conversation within the dB level. |
Emits low/high/ultrasonic sound to overwhelm the microphones. |
|
Effect on Human |
There are no known side effects. The device's function is similar to that of a TV's white noise or being in a loud restaurant. |
We don’t fully know the long-term effects or side effects from prolonged exposure, so proceed with caution. Some have reported no effect, while others have reported headaches, nausea, and even physical pain. |
|
Effectiveness |
Targets a range of dB sound and nullifies that completely, but if the conversation is louder than the coverage range, it can be ineffective. |
Overwhelm microphones that can pick up the frequency and render the recording unusable, but it fully requires the microphone to be able to hear the specific range of noise. |
|
Distance |
Best used when placed between the conversation and the microphone at close range. |
Best used in a small enclosed environment where the inaudible sound can be amplified by bouncing around. |
|
Intrusiveness |
High, since it requires an audible noise to equal the speech dB |
Circumstantial since it could be completely unnoticed, but it could also interfere with other devices, such as hearing aids, conference calls, and other assistive tools. |
|
Legality |
Please note that usage may be restricted; consult your local laws for information on legal usage and policies. |
Please note that usage may be restricted; consult your local laws for information on legal usage and policies. |
Legitimate Reasons To Need An Audio Jammer
Privacy and safety are always a top priority, and any way to mitigate risk will improve your peace of mind. Working for the Spy Centre has taught me many valuable lessons, and one of the most significant is that ignoring a problem can lead to unforeseen consequences. Even if you think you know the risk, the odds are that you're better off not taking them.
Here are some examples of legitimate ways people have used audio jammers:
-
Confidential Information: In business, confidentiality is crucial, and keeping information from competitors can make the difference between growth and failure. Imagine you have an idea for a business venture, but you're afraid that sharing this information could jeopardize your current position. An audio jammer can help ensure that the conversation stays within the room.
-
Preventing undesired recording: Imagine for a moment that you are an actor and you're rehearsing the “Big Scene,” The one where the bad guy turns out to be the good guy, and the good guy was, for some reason, a robot all along. Using an audio jammer can prevent that information from leaking out to the press, keeping intellectual property at risk, and the big twist a secret.
-
Reduce Risk: Consulting a lawyer about a situation requires that the information remain confidential. Some lawyers carry an audio jammer to establish trust with their clients, allowing them to speak more openly and freely. This allows the lawyer to decide on a plan of action, since a lawyer is only as good as the information they are working with.
-
Research and Development: In Formula 1, the difference between winning and losing could come down to the most minor detail—everything from event strategy to a single bolt. The last thing any team would want is for any information to get into a competitor's hands.
Limitations With Audio Jammers
Just like any tool used for protection, there is always a “but” associated with it. Situations vary, but the three significant issues that need to be addressed are: Legality, A False Sense of Security, and Unknown Long-Term Effects.
-
Legality: Let’s start with the elephant in the room: Is it legal to use, own, and operate? There isn’t a catch-all answer to this question, and it ultimately depends on the context of the situation. As stated above, there are two different types of audio jammers, and one of those jammers is capable of producing non-harmful white noise to mask a conversation. Since televisions are legal, you would assume that they are as well, right? Not always the case. And, even if you have concrete proof that your local laws allow for this device to be used, it could only apply to specific models, the country of origin, or even the environment in which it is being used. In some cases, confidentiality paperwork may also need to be signed, agreeing to the use of an audio jammer during the session. That's why, and to reiterate, you should always consult a lawyer regarding potential legal issues.
-
False Sense of Security: Relying on an audio jammer as your only safeguard against unwanted information being leaked will only protect the situation to a certain extent. As stated in the preceding paragraphs, there are ways to defeat them, and these need to be taken into account as well. Information can be recovered even when it's been seemingly diluted. So, be proactive in these situations and ensure that aspects such as the environment are thoroughly tested and retested to cover any potential air gaps that might pose a threat.
-
Long-Term Effects: We honestly don’t know the long-term effects of consistently being bombarded with high-frequency sound, as some of the audio jammers produce. These devices are designed with one goal in mind: to disrupt audio equipment at a close range. Some people have reported things such as headaches, nausea, and even physical pain, but their long-term effects are not truly known.
Legal & Ethical (must read)
I would like to reiterate that this article is intended for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or recommendations. Many countries tightly regulate or outright prohibit the usage of any jamming equipment. Before purchasing an audio jammer, please consult your local laws. If the situation involves business or legal matters, also consult a lawyer to ensure you are protected. Even if your situation requires privacy protection, the legal system may not view it in the same way, so please do your due diligence to ensure you are protected first.
As for the ethical application, it’s always best to ensure that everyone involved is aware that an audio jammer will be used first. Since some audio jamming devices can cause havoc to things such as hearing aids or even other electronic devices, respect their consent and, just as stated above, allow them to inform you if they are experiencing any of the effects that have popped up with the usage of high-frequency sound.
Bottom line: Should you buy one?
There are situations where an audio jammer is the best option, even if it’s not perfect. When privacy and confidentiality are necessary, they can significantly enhance the level of protection, especially when the alternative is no protection at all. However, these are just tools, and like any tool, they are only as effective as the user who uses them.
If you're suspicious that unauthorized recording poses a real threat, then the next step would be to ensure your purchase and application are legal. From there, test and retest before deploying it for the situation, take adequate precautions for your needs, and consider other alternatives, such as access control and metal detectors to prevent the unauthorized usage of a hidden recorder. Many people consider silent audio jammers since they seem unintrusive, but that is why they fail. By being intrusive and setting up prescreen security measures, it will provide the right peace of mind you're looking for.